Auna's Predictability Problem: The Risk-Sharing Contract That Broke the Risk-Sharing Story
Mexico finally inflects and cash conversion hits a record — but a 500,000-life oncology contract in Colombia delivered the third 'extraordinary' surprise in three quarters, and management's own words say it knows.
AUNA · Earnings Call · 2026-11-18
Three hits, one quarter, and a word nobody used last year
Auna's Q3 2026 was not a bad quarter in the ordinary sense. Revenue grew 10% FX-neutral, free cash flow nearly doubled year-to-date to PEN 626 million, the cash conversion cycle went from negative 9 days to negative 15, and leverage ticked down sequentially to 3.5x against a 3x medium-term target. Underneath the noise, this is a business generating cash better than it ever has. And yet the quarter arrived carrying three separate "extraordinary" items: an oncology risk-sharing contract in Colombia whose medical costs blew through contractual assumptions, regulatory price caps on high-cost oncology medicines enacted mid-August, and PEN 18 million of revenue adjustments from prior-years' billing reconciliation in Peru. Gisele Ferrero put a ruler on the Colombian damage: of the roughly $4 million year-over-year drop in Colombia's EBITDA, she estimated “approximately 70% of that was due specifically to this oncology risk-sharing contract, which has already been terminated. And the remaining 30% is due to the price caps” — Gisele Ferrero, Chief Financial Officer or CFO · 2026-11-18. The new vocabulary in this transcript is telling. oncology risk sharing contract did not exist as a phrase in Auna's prior three calls. Neither did contractual assumptions, nor particular contract. The company spent 2026 up to now selling risk-sharing as the mechanism of safety; this quarter it discovered the mechanism is only as safe as the actuarial guess inside it.The paradox at the center of the thesis
Go back to May 2026. Asked about Colombia's regulatory risk, Jesús Zamora was emphatic: “I've seen -- we've seen the worst of regulatory changes and political upheaval with President Petro. And I think in both scenarios of the current leading polls and candidates to the presidency, I think the Colombian health care sector will not get worse than we've seen in 2025.” — Jesús Zamora Leon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-05-20 On the same call, the risk sharing contracts book was pitched on its stability: “Our risk sharing business have high predictability, cash predictability and lower working capital cycle” — Jesús Zamora Leon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-05-20, with only a small, temporary margin dilution at onset. Both statements now read badly. The worst was not behind Colombia — a single newer PGP contract covering roughly 500,000 lives absorbed an unusually high incidence of advanced-stage cancer cases and cost far more than modeled, and price caps landed on top of it. What was sold as the predictability layer of the model is precisely what produced the least predictable quarter of the year. Zamora also insisted it was idiosyncratic: “we do not think what has occurred with one of our PGP contracts, a newer contract, has any contagion effect or any replicability in our rest of our PGPs and PIPs contract. So we don't think it's a sector issue.” — Jesús Zamora Leon, Chief Executive Officer or CEO · 2026-11-18 Perhaps. But investors are being asked to take that on faith one quarter after being told Colombia had bottomed — and the CEO's own language has changed from confidence to caution, with Colombia now expected to "gradually recover" rather than lead.That is a remarkable thing for a CEO to say out loud. qualitative nature of predictability as an explicit management objective is an admission that the sell-side case has been built on a property the company has not reliably delivered. He called them “dirty quarters with a lot of extraordinary events” — Jesús Zamora Leon, Chief Executive Officer or CEO · 2026-11-18. Three in a row is not an accident; it is a control environment.it's important that you also take note that we're working on the qualitative nature of predictability. We cannot be about these exogenous events. We need to make sure that we make sure that, first of all, we have full control of what we're doing in the services that we're delivering.