Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

Grupo Aval: The Bond Book Blinked

A 29% profit drop was a rates-mark story, not a credit story — and the new 2027 ROE promise now carries the burden of proof.
AVAL · Earnings Call · 2026-11-11

The Bond Book Blinked

Grupo Aval’s third quarter is not a credit-shock quarter. It is a rates-mark quarter. Attributable net income fell to COP 368 billion, down 29% year over year, and ROAE dropped to 7.9%. Maria Lorena Gutierrez Botero pinned it on two forces: “our attributable net income was COP 368 billion, down 29%... Our ROAE for the quarter was 7.9%” — Maria Gutierrez Botero, Host / Possibly Investor Relations or Senior Management · 2026-11-11 — a lower NIM on investments after an exceptional second quarter and one-time effects from the Itau retail acquisition. The mechanics matter. Loan spreads are actually getting better: NIM on loans rose to 4.9%, up 44 basis points QoQ and 30 bp YoY, with retail NIM at 6.1% and commercial at 3.9%. The consolidated spread between yield on loans and cost of deposits reached 5.7%, up 18 bp QoQ and 25 bp YoY. But the investment book swung violently: “our NIM on investments fell to negative 0.1%, down from 4.7% a year ago and an exceptional high 8.7% during second quarter 2026.” — Diego Saravia, CFO · 2026-11-11 That is the company-unique NIM on investment problem. Rising local yields marked down fixed-income portfolios; hedges in derivatives and FX produced COP 424 billion of gains that cushioned the hit but did not erase it. This also explains why the guidance looks odd. Management now guides 2026 consolidated NIM at 4.1% area, with NIM on loans at 4.5%, even though loan spreads are improving. The missing piece is the investment portfolio. On the prior call, Diego Saravia said “we are building in a NIM investments of 2% into our figures. However, on the NIM and loans, we are seeing our strategy really paying out.” — Diego Saravia, CFO · 2026-08-13 A 2% assumption has become a negative print. That is not a small rounding error; it is the difference between a respectable bank quarter and a 7.9% ROE.

Itau: Neutral Math, Noisy Optics

This was the first quarter including the Itau retail business. Gross loans grew 4.7% QoQ to COP 207 trillion, with Itau adding roughly COP 6.3 trillion; deposits rose 1.3% to COP 224 trillion, including COP 4.3 trillion from Itau. Strip Itau out and loans still grew 1.4% QoQ and 6.8% YoY, so the core franchise is not shrinking. But the accounting made the quarter look worse than the economics. The day-one provision lifted net cost of risk to 2.5%, or 2.1% excluding Itau. Other income included COP 205 billion from accounting recognition of the deal, largely offsetting the COP 217 billion provision. Diego’s explanation is worth putting in full because it is the cleanest defense of the quarter:

There's no goodwill. This is -- we're not bringing in a company. We're bringing in a portfolio. However, the way accounting works is we calculate the fair value of the business. and compare to the money actually paid, that generates roughly COP 200 billion. And the day after we do that, we report a provision expense for approximately the same amount. Net-net, the impact after tax of bringing in Itau and the results for this quarter were around COP 7 billion -- COP 7,000 million. So it is basically neutral to our P&L at this point.

Diego Saravia, CFO · 2026-11-11
Neutral to P&L, yes. Neutral to perception, no. The Itau transaction also brought COP 45 billion of one-time integration expenses and, separately, a COP 70 billion industry-and-commerce tax hit from Cali and Yopal. Reported cost-to-income rose to 52.6%; excluding one-time items it would have been 53.8%. And the Cost of risk optics cut both ways: 2.5% headline, 2.1% ex-Itau, against a 2026 guide of 2% area. The strategic logic is still the mix shift away from payroll loans toward credit cards and personal loans, which reprice faster and are less liability-sensitive. But this quarter shows the transition costs are lumpy.

From Tax Defense to Fiscal Hope

The keyword list tells a subtle story. A quarter ago the company’s language was dominated by Artificial intelligence, fixed income, technology strategy and the new administration. Two quarters ago the top themes were equity tax, AV Villas core capital, inflation expectations and local tax. Today the fresh language is fiscal adjustment, Economic Rescue Law, labor regulation and key sectors. The tax debate has not disappeared — Carlos Gomez of HSBC asked directly about tax reform, and Diego said he could not comment until the reform is clearer, while using a 35% standard tax rate in guidance. But management is no longer organizing the call around defending against a tax hit. It is organizing it around the hope that fiscal repair unlocks growth. The macro backdrop is genuinely difficult. Inflation ran at 6.3% in September and October, the Central Bank kept its policy rate at 12.25% after a 25 bp hike in September, and the government’s own numbers imply a fiscal deficit near 9.4% of GDP in 2027 without adjustment. The Economic Rescue Law aims at more than 4 percentage points of GDP adjustment by 2030. Maria Lorena’s summary is blunt: “The near-term outlook remains challenging. Growth is expected to slightly decelerate given the fiscal adjustments in processes, while local rates will continue high, given persistent though lower inflation.” — Maria Gutierrez Botero, Host / Possibly Investor Relations or Senior Management · 2026-11-11 Oil is part of that mix; higher Oil prices from the Middle East conflict feed inflation and keep the rate path uncertain. That is the chain from geopolitics to Aval’s investment book. The contrast with prior calls is stark. In August, Maria Lorena was still flagging local tax risk in Bogota: “We are a little worried with the local taxes... It increases one of the local tax, that is ICA, 30%.” — Maria Gutierrez Botero, CEO · 2026-08-13 Today that concern is below the surface. The new narrative is conditional: if Congress approves a credible adjustment and the new administration restores fiscal confidence, rates can fall and loan growth can recover. That is a hope, not yet an observable trend.

The 2027 Promise and the Proof Burden

The guidance is the real news. For 2026, management now targets ROE in the 9% area, a shade below the 9.25% that Diego called “basically maintaining our guidance” in August. For 2027, it introduced an initial ROE target of around 12%, with loan growth of 9.5%, consolidated NIM of 4.4% and NIM on loans of 5%. That is a big step up, and it depends on three things: full Itau benefit, continued loan repricing, and rate cuts beginning in the second half of 2027. Diego expects the tightening cycle to end with a final 25 bp hike in December and cuts to begin in 2H27. If the investment book swings again, 12% becomes harder to defend. The offset is the non-bank franchise. Aval Fiduciaria delivered record trust fee revenue of COP 486.7 billion, up 12.7% YoY, net income of COP 84.8 billion, up 14.9%, and ROE of 42.3%, with COP 211.8 trillion in assets under management and a 24.1% market share. The integration of four trust companies has cut the cost-to-income ratio by more than 10 percentage points and captured synergies equal to 40% of the cost base. That is a real trust company story, not boilerplate. Corficolombiana also closed a legal chapter: the U.S. DPA case related to Ruta del Sol 2 was dismissed on October 26 after obligations were satisfied. Nonfinancial income is guided to 1.3x 2025. Still, the consolidated equity story remains bank-led. A 12% ROE in 2027 is credible only if the NIM on investments normalizes and the Itau mix shift earns its keep. The quarter just reported shows how quickly the bond book can turn a good lending quarter into a 7.9% ROE. That is the tension investors have to underwrite.