Grupo Cibest Spins Off Nequi, Then Quietly Lowers Its Own Ceiling
A 21.7% ROE quarter, upgraded loan guidance, and a long-term anchor that slipped to 20% as Colombia's higher-for-longer rates cut both ways
CIB · Earnings Call · 2026-11-10
Two Numbers, One Story
Grupo Cibest reported COP 2 trillion of net income for the third quarter, a 21.7% return on equity, and promptly raised its 2026 loan growth outlook from 7–8% to 8–9%. On the surface: a Colombian bank compounding through a messy macro backdrop — a tense government transition, an August earthquake in the southwest, and a fiscal consolidation fight that Laura Clavijo, the group's chief economist, called “the talk of the town” — Laura Clavijo, Executive / Senior Management · 2026-11-10.
But the number that matters sits on slide 26, not slide 24. For 2027, management guided net income growth of 8–10% to roughly COP 9.2–9.3 trillion and an ROE of 21.5–22%. Then, in the Q&A, Mauricio Botero Wolff set the anchor somewhere else entirely: “when interest rates start coming down, and we reach more stable inflation and interest rate levels along with GDP growth and ROE should be around 20%” — Mauricio Botero Wolff, Executive / Senior Management · 2026-11-10. The long-term build — NIM of 6.5–6.8%, 4% inflation, a 29–30% tax rate, cost of risk of about 2% — lands at 20%, not 22%.
That is not a shock given the macro. What makes it a story is the framing: 2027 is explicitly a rates tailwind year. Cibest is one of the few banks globally that wants the rising interest rates environment the rest of the market is pricing as a threat — “we're going to start 2027 at a higher rate, and we expect that rate to be stable until the fourth quarter of the year. So that explains the expected increase in net interest margin” — Mauricio Botero Wolff, Executive / Senior Management · 2026-11-10. Colombia's policy rate could reach 12.5%, inflation peaks near 7.3% in the first half of 2027 before falling to 5.5%. When that reverses, so does the margin.
The second kicker: guidance implies NIM up about 10 basis points but cost of risk up 30–40, from a 1.7% nine-month run-rate to 1.9–2.1% in 2027. Analyst Yuri Fernandes asked precisely this — why risk-adjusted margins compress — and got an honest answer: “the growth itself demands provision” — Mauricio Botero Wolff, Executive / Senior Management · 2026-11-10. Commercial growth into lower-yield, institutional-funded corporate tickets, plus a push back into consumer lending risk brackets they had vacated, plus earthquake and El Niño overlays. Growth here is not free.
The Fees That Ate The Fees
The most quietly revealing keyword in this quarter's deck is not a growth theme at all — it is fee expenses, which rocketed to the second-highest-momentum term in the call. Why? Because Cibest's 15.5% year-over-year net fee growth is partly a cost story, not a revenue story. Mauricio was explicit that 2026's fee leverage is unrepeatable: “for 2027, that is probably not going to be sustainable. So we're going to see revenue on fees growing more in line with the expenses” — Mauricio Botero Wolff, Executive / Senior Management · 2026-11-10 — both at 10–12%, net fees around 12%. The 21% fee income ratio is a floor that can drift toward 25% only if margins compress.
Something else has quietly fallen off. In the August call, the standout driver of net interest income was an arbitrage: carry trade and international investors buying Colombian sovereigns through the bank's cheap funding, lifting the investment portfolio's contribution. That theme is gone. Net interest income fell 4.9% quarter-on-quarter on, in management's words, the normalization of treasury income after an exceptionally strong second quarter. The investment portfolio that was Cibest's earnings engine in Q2 is now its drag. Nobody on the call needed to be reminded; the 7.4% NIM versus 6.6% a quarter earlier tells the story.
Nequi: Optionality at a 23% ROE, Cloaked in Accounting Fog
On September 1, Nequi became an independent entity wholly owned by the holding company, capitalized with COP 600 billion and a 13% solvency ratio. The numbers are genuinely startling for a neobank: NIM of 18.1%, 24 million active users out of 29 million, 7 in 10 Colombian adults with an account, 3.9 million for whom it is the only account, and 42% of Bre-B ecosystem payments. ROE was 23% in the quarter, 28% excluding spin-off one-offs, with guidance of 28% for 2026 and 28–30% for 2027.
But Nequi contributes roughly 2% of group net income. Juan Carlos Mora framed it as an avenue of growth rather than a earnings driver: “probably in 2030 will be something around 8% to 10%. If the growth is strong, particularly on loans and depending on the credit cycle” — Juan Uribe, CEO · 2026-11-10. An IPO is not on the table near term — “we are not thinking about an IPO in the short term” — Juan Uribe, CEO · 2026-11-10 — though he conceded the new structure opens strategic alternatives.
The fog is worth flagging. Analyst Santiago Villanueva caught a genuine gap: Nequi shows a COP 21 billion loss at the Superintendencia Financiera versus a COP 111 billion profit discussed on the call. Mauricio's answer invoked accounting figures — one month of P&L on an historic balance sheet, with managerial net income of COP 160–180 billion for 2026 converging to formal accounting in 2027. This is not malfeasance; it is a spinoff whose economics are being described in a language the reporting does not yet speak. Investors should anchor on the convergence, not the quarter.
The Cap Rate Bet
Perhaps the freshest idea on the call was buried in the last question: Colombia's consumer interest rate cap, currently around 28.4%, may be revised upward by Congress. The cap rate keyword is now the highest-momentum term in Cibest's entire keyword history, up sharply from a peripheral mention last quarter. Management's read is counterintuitive for a lender — it is a chance to expand the addressable market, not a margin grab. “What happened with the cap rate... is that generates exclusion to some people that due to their level of risk that cap rate don't allow formal financial institutions to lend them. If that ceiling increases, probably that will include more people” — Juan Uribe, CEO · 2026-11-10. Juan Carlos noted Nequi already runs about 6% of loans under a different cap, and that there are six distinct caps in Colombia, not one.
Wrapping it all is the macro that will decide whether any of this is financed. The fiscal adjustment narrative — a rescue bill worth 2.4% of GDP, a base case of roughly a 1.4% adjustment via spending cuts, a central government deficit of 7.9% of GDP in 2027 — is the single variable that gates both the loan-growth upgrade and the ROE. Mora's own conditionality is telling: the 9–10% loan growth guide is offered provided the fiscal deficit narrows in an orderly and gradually way.
So the honest read of this quarter: operations are excellent, the balance sheet is conservative (98% double leverage versus a 120% tolerance, Bancolombia standalone solvency at 13.7%, cost-to-income at 46.6%), and the growth is real. But the earnings mix is shifting toward lower-margin commercial loans funded more expensively, the fee engine needs cost cuts to look good, the treasury arbitrage has closed, and the long-term return anchor has been re-set to 20%. Cibest is not breaking — it is being honest about what the next cycle pays.