Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

Cargojet's Record Quarter Is a Swap, Not a Step-Up

Record Q3 revenue and EBITDA, leverage at target, ROIC climbing — but the growth has migrated from e-commerce to charter, and the UPS crutch walks out after Q4.
CJT.TO · Earnings Call · 2026-11-12

The record that hides a mix shift

Pauline Dhillon opened with the numbers everyone wanted: record third-quarter revenue of CAD 286.5 million, record adjusted EBITDA of CAD 90.2 million, net earnings up 117% to CAD 19.1 million. Aaron McKay then did the honest thing and decomposed it — ex-fuel revenue of CAD 265.9 million, up 20.9% year-over-year, against a fuel surcharge line that inflates the top line while diluting the margin by roughly 190 basis points. “We estimate the year-over-year dilutive impact of the surcharge mechanism on adjusted EBITDA margin in the third quarter was approximately 190 basis points with no material impact on adjusted EBITDA.” — Aaron McKay, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-12 Fine. That is bookkeeping, not economics. The economics are in the segments, and there the story is a rotation. Charter produced CAD 61.9 million, up 88.1% year-over-year and 13.2% sequentially. Hybrid ACMI produced CAD 60.5 million, up 10.8% on both axes — the first genuinely clean comparison since the East-West to North-South transition that management spent five quarters apologising for. Domestic overnight, excluding CAD 5.3 million of fuel pass-through, grew 6.3%. Nothing is broken. But the engine that carried the equity story through 2024 and 2025 has downshifted noticeably.

The word that disappeared

Here is the quiet tell. For at least two years, e-commerce was the single most prominent theme in Cargojet's own keyword profile — top of the list in the 2024 Q2, 2025 Q3 and 2026 Q1 periods, with management crediting Canadian consumers and secondary-market retail shifts for double-digit domestic growth. In the just-reported quarter's curated top 30, e-commerce is simply gone. Not ranked lower. Absent. That is not an editorial accident. It matches the numbers. In February, Pauline guided to domestic growth in the single digits and described the prior year's 17% as something that surprised even her: “We remain committed to hopefully seeing single-digit growth in Q1, but it's going to be, I guess, on purchasing powers and what the consumer market does.” — Pauline Dhillon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-02-25 Six percent ex-fuel is the delivery of that guidance. The narrative has been retired because it stopped being a growth driver — the seasonal read now is that peak demand will be broadly comparable to 2025, which is another way of saying no step-up. Into that vacuum stepped a genuinely new, company-unique theme: Miami, which enters the quarter as one of the highest-momentum keywords in the entire profile. Three weekly frequencies from Hamilton beginning December 2, sold in advance to existing integrators and forwarders, connecting European and Chinese inbound freight into South America southbound and produce and flowers northbound. It is a clever piece of network geometry. It is also, by management's own framing, a reallocation of aircraft rather than an addition of capacity.

One Fleet is really a capital-allocation story

What management has actually changed is not the fleet, it is the discipline applied to it. The company's current keyword set reads like an operating manifesto — asset utilization at the very top, existing fleet, network efficiency, cost discipline, return on invested capital. And unlike most such manifestos, this one is visible in the P&L. ROIC moved to 5.8% from 5.0% sequentially. Net leverage hit 2.5x, inside the long-term target range management had said would take until the end of 2026. Free cash flow was CAD 62.1 million — versus CAD 152 million a year ago, but that comparison is misleading because last year's number was inflated by sale-and-leaseback proceeds, so the current figure is the cleaner one. Aaron was unusually direct about the hierarchy: “Our focus right now from a metrics point of view is very clearly on ROIC and generating high returns on the assets through higher asset utilization.” — Aaron McKay, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-12 And the Miami route is designed to prove it costs nothing: “We have no intention to go out and purchase new aircraft. We're utilizing the same fleet during the day for these flights. So there's no CapEx coming to handle this new business.” — Pauline Dhillon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-12 That is the pitch — earnings growth with a flat asset base. It is the right pitch for a CAD 1 billion market cap company whose stock has not rewarded expansion. But a 5.8% return on invested capital remains a modest absolute number, and the improvement is coming off a low base as the denominator finally rolls past the fleet-buying peak McKay flagged back in August.

The UPS hole — and a script on repeat

The uncomfortable question arrived from Walter Spracklin, and it was the right one: what does charter look like in 2027 once the UPS MD-11 support flying ends? Pauline's answer was directional rather than quantitative. Ajay Virmani filled in the substance: “We will replace the UPS flying. Those assets will be all gainfully employed, maybe not on day 1, but we are hoping that within the first quarter, we will have the placements for those.” — Ajay Virmani, Executive Chairman · 2026-11-12 Note that the +88.1% charter growth being celebrated contains the UPS revenue that is about to leave. Management is simultaneously crediting itself for the replacement and still booking the thing being replaced. That is not a criticism — the South America and China flying is real and has commenced — but it means the 2027 charter base is unproven, and investors should treat it that way until the first quarter prints. The MD 11 event has slid from a top-three keyword to a fading footnote, which is exactly how a temporary windfall should look on the way out. Less flattering is the rhetoric. Asked about pricing, Pauline returned to a metaphor she used almost word for word three months ago:

We are the best steakhouse in the city, and we're changing from Keg pricing... We are assessing the product that we provide in the marketplace, the lanes that we go into, and we're realigning the pricing to meet those needs and those lanes.

Pauline Dhillon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-12
On the August call the line was: “We recognize that we're the best steakhouse in the city, we're not going to charge keg pricing anymore.” — Pauline Dhillon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-08-11 Same restaurateur, same joke, same quarter over quarter. The underlying initiative — repricing mid-market and shorter-dated contracts, as flagged in the August Q&A — is legitimate. But when a CEO recycles her own punchline, it usually means the messaging is being polished faster than the execution is advancing, and analysts will start pricing that in. The follow-up question, whether price can rise inside existing contracts, got a flat no: contracts are contracts, and the next big renewals sit in 2029 and 2030.

What actually changed

Two things, both real. First, ACMI has stopped bleeding. In August, asked about DHL volumes, management said plainly “they haven't given us any indication at this time.” — Pauline Dhillon, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-08-11 This week the tone is different: “Our customers that we use, DHL and a few others have definitely indicated that the trade and traffic is up substantially from where we were, let's say, a year ago.” — Ajay Virmani, Executive Chairman · 2026-11-12 That is a genuine change of fact, not of spin. Second, a supply-side gift that Cargojet did not create but is monetising: elevated fuel cost and the fuel surcharge mechanism that neutralises it in dollars, and the broader dislocation in global air freight that has pushed jet fuel prices to the top of the market's 30-day price-mover list alongside airlines. Cargojet is a second-derivative play on trade friction — wars, tariffs and re-routing all make air cargo scarce, and its integrator customers make the call first. So: a company that has stopped growing its domestic engine, replaced it with chartered utilisation of assets it already owns, and finally earned the balance sheet latitude to buy back stock (76,749 shares last quarter, NCIB renewed) and grow the dividend. That is a decent industrial story. It is not the e-commerce growth story investors bought in 2024, and the transcript — including the words no longer in it — says management knows it.