Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

FirstGroup: A £1bn Half That Earns 15% Less

Revenue up 21%, EPS down 15%, and a business deliberately selling off its own asset base — the UK transport group's transition is now the whole story
FGP.L · Earnings Call · 2026-11-17

The headline that doesn't add up

FirstGroup reported its half year to September 2026 and the two numbers sit awkwardly side by side: adjusted revenue up 21% to just over £1 billion, adjusted EPS down 15.2% to 8.4p. CEO Graham Sutherland opened on the front foot — “leaving us on course to maintain our adjusted earnings per share for the full year” — Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17 — before CFO Ryan Mangold supplied the bruising detail: “adjusted EPS saw a 15.2% decrease year-on-year to 8.4p, primarily due to the launch and ramp-up costs in sterling” — Ryan Mangold, CFO or Finance Executive · 2026-11-17. The reconciliation is clean enough once you know where to look. Group adjusted operating profit actually rose 6.7% to £110.5m, and Bus did the heavy lifting — revenue up 7% to £750m, operating profit up 18% to £50.2m, margin from 6.1% to 6.7%. The drag came from Rail: roughly £8m of launch costs on the new Stirling service, a scheduled £1.8m step-up in the infrastructure charge at Lumo, and the persistent cost of price competition on the East Coast mainline. Analysts did not let it slide — Berenberg's Jack Cummings asked directly for the H2 building blocks that turn a 15% first-half decline into a flat year. Mangold's answer was reasonable but back-loaded: London Overground improving toward "mid-single-digit operating profits," Stirling reaching breakeven by the outturn, and the traditional second-half heaviness of Bus. That is a lot of second-half execution riding on a maintained full-year number.

The great unwinding

The more important story is structural, and it is a story of subtraction. FirstGroup is being dismantled at the edges by policy. Its two remaining DfT TOC franchises, GWR and Avanti West Coast, are being taken into public ownership: “Both GWR and Avanti West Coast will be nationalized before the end of the financial year” — Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17. Meanwhile Bus franchising is converting the group's owned regional depots and diesel fleet into contracted, lower-margin but capital light operations. The fleet math is stark — the owned regional bus fleet shrinks from roughly 4,500 vehicles to 2,900. Most managements would sell that as bad news. FirstGroup is framing it as a return-of-capital event, and the numbers partly back the pitch. Asset sales are recycling cash: the West Yorkshire depot agreement, the South Yorkshire and Wales disposals, and the West Yorkshire/Mistral proceeds all feed the buyback. Post-tax return on invested capital has climbed to 13.3%, up 280 basis points and now comfortably above WACC — the cleanest single argument that shrinking the asset base is value-accretive rather than defensive. Leverage sits at 0.8x adjusted net debt cover, well inside the framework.

Where the growth actually lives

The growth engine the market is being asked to underwrite is Open Access rail — the unsubsidised, competition-on-the-rails model. Revenue there grew 13% in the half, and management guided full-year Open Access revenue to roughly £130m with an 18% East Coast margin preserved through the price war. Sutherland was pointed about the strategy: “our leading strategy here is maintain our utilization and still be very, very competitive in the market” — Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17. Two further applications (Hereford–Paddington and Paignton–Paddington) are pending a decision within months; the Rochdale bid was knocked back again.

Operate without government subsidy, Open Access services drive productivity, create jobs and bring significant benefits to passengers and communities.

Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17
Alongside it, London Overground — taken over in May — is guided to circa £300m revenue, and Business & Coach is quietly becoming the diversification story: revenue up 11% to £123m, 65% contracted, anchored by the Sizewell C worker transport contract that echoes the group's Hinkley Point C experience.

The policy swing nobody priced

The half's damage came partly from a policy change that is now reversing. The move to a £3 fare cap in England dented commercial volumes; those are now stabilising, and the January 2027 shift to a £2 cap is a tailwind. Sutherland: “where we've had GBP 2 fare in place before, we have generally seen a little bit of a volume uplift” — Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17. Regional Bus margins already recovered to 9.7% from 8% despite the prior year's national insurance and funding hits — a reminder that policy changes cut both ways, and that the Regional Bus franchise reset is where the medium-term portfolio margin story sits.

Capital returns — and a small credibility test

The cash story is the loudest signal. Management lifted its three-year free cash commitment to over £500m from the £435m guided at the Mistral sale, added a fresh £50m to the existing £100m buyback, and nudged the interim dividend to 2.3p. The cash generation upgrade rests partly on franchising asset sales rather than pure operations, which is why analysts probed it — and why the tone tightened:

The bottom line is we have a 3-year commitment. We're going to deliver it, and we won't give a running commentary in every deal we do.

Graham Sutherland, CEO or Senior Executive · 2026-11-17
Two small blemishes are worth flagging for the careful reader. The CEO described the dividend as a "5% increase to 2.3p"; the CFO called the same number a "4.5%" increase. And the West Yorkshire asset sale was variously cited as a £109m agreement, a £100m agreement, and £55m "received in the second half." These are almost certainly different slices of one transaction, but precision is the currency of a turnaround narrative, and this call was occasionally loose with it.

The verdict

FirstGroup is no longer a rail franchise operator with a bus business attached; it is becoming a capital-light, contracted, cash-returning transport group, mid-surgery. The revenue growth is real, the ROIC improvement is real, and the £500m cash commitment is a genuine marker. But the equity case now rests on a second-half that must deliver a 15% first-half EPS hole back to flat — while nationalisation removes two franchises and franchising removes the asset base. That is a defensible trade, but it is a trade on execution and policy timing, not on the headline growth. The market will judge this management on whether the £2 fare cap actually lifts volumes and whether Stirling truly breaks even by year-end.