3i Is Buying Its Own 21% Discount While Action Starts Cutting Prices
A 5% half, a second £750m buyback, and a shrink problem that arrived just as the France narrative finally flipped
III.L · Earnings Call · 2026-11-12
Buying the dip in itself
3i's half-year numbers are almost boringly good: a 5% total return, net asset value per share of £31.54 at end-September, and £1.9bn of value growth of which Action alone supplied £1.5bn. Foreign exchange took £0.47 a share off NAV after a 78%-per-share currency gain the prior year, and the dividend paid in the half cost another £0.48. Add it up and you get a company whose crown asset is compounding while its share price is not. That gap is the actual story. The first £750m buyback programme retired about 29.5m shares at an average of £24.95 — roughly a fifth below the period-end NAV — and a second £750m tranche now runs to the end of May 2027. Simon Borrows did not dress it up: “we announced the second GBP 750 million buyback to continue the purchase of 3i shares while they trade at a discount to our portfolio value.” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12 Funding is not a stretch — net debt of £1.3bn, gearing of 4%, over £1bn of liquidity, and an Action dividend machine behind it. When asked whether the buyback would lean on the revolver, James Hatchley pointed to Action's twice-yearly dividends, lower gearing, potential realizations and end-September liquidity as the four legs of the stool.Action: a deflation machine that still compounds
Action's operating numbers to the end of October were €14.3bn of net sales and €1.96bn of operating EBITDA, with P9 sales up 13.6% and EBITDA up 10.7%. LTM run-rate EBITDA of €2.8bn at the 18.5x post-discount multiple implies a €51.4bn enterprise value; 3i's increased 67.5% holding is carried at £25.5bn. Cash stood at €1.39bn after a €450m dividend in May, and roughly €2.25bn of operating cash is expected this year. That is the cash generation underwriting the buyback. The engine is volume, not price. Over nine months Action cut prices on more than 1,000 items in its fixed assortment — about half the range — with most reductions in the 5% to 10% band, funded by buying power and the transaction pickup that follows. The competitive response has faded: “we saw when we reduced prices this time last year, some people reacted to that. But we've definitely seen less people reacting as we are rolling these prices down across the last 9 months.” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12 Contrast that with May 2025, when the same management team described store prices as merely “about 1% to 2% cheaper than the store last year” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2025-05-15. The price investment has become deliberate, structural and self-funded rather than defensive. Geographically the tone has changed too. Slovenia and Croatia opened strongly — “In Slovenia, the sales were actually exceptionally strong by any -- almost all previous benchmarks.” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12 Poland, the market everyone worries about, is running positive like-for-likes, double-digit sales growth and one of the group's best margins despite weekly supermarket price wars. Guidance is at least 400 new stores, like-for-likes around 4%, and a 14.7%-14.8% margin.The new crack: shrink and absenteeism
Here is the genuinely new item, and it is not a macro one. Action's third-quarter margin fell about 90 basis points year on year, and the cause was operational:Management's fix is a grab-bag of labelling, in-store display and extra security, plus tighter labour scheduling in peak season, with the cost of the measures framed as immaterial against the shrink itself. The proof point is October: the EBITDA margin moved above 15% for the month, which by Borrows's arithmetic generated as much profit as the whole preceding quarter. That is why the full-year 14.7%-14.8% guide survives a soft Q3 — but it also means the guidance now leans heavily on peak trading behaving normally, with diesel already a roughly €12m headwind year-to-date.We have seen a jump in shrink this year, which has been higher than in prior years in certain countries. And the other, we saw quite a lot of absenteeism across different countries. So we had to pull in shorter-term workers to deal with that, and it had an impact upon labor costs.
What quietly stopped being said
A year ago this call was a France call. The prior Q&A opened with French like-for-likes that were “indeed negative” — Simon Borrows, Chief Executive Officer · 2025-11-13, and the explanation was fiscal and social:Today France is described as not materially disrupted by unrest, with lower footfall on specific days and continued share gains — “we're over 23 million weekly visits now” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12 and, on third-party data, further share taken in Q3. Food inflation, lighter baskets, the political situation, Temu and Lidl's non-food test concept have all vanished from the script. That is a real improvement in the narrative, not just a re-framing — and it is being achieved while cutting prices. Two absences are less comfortable. First, the realization cycle: a year ago management expected a pickup much more in the following year than the current one, and the current characterization is a European mid-market that has been “relatively thin for a good part of the year” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12, with later-stage reviews only now appearing. Second, the U.S.: a year ago there was nothing to add beyond a research project; now “we probably have about 20 professionals working in the U.S. at this point” — Simon Borrows, CEO · 2026-11-12, with no stores or distribution centres yet and Bulgaria also queued for next year. That is a real cost line arriving ahead of any revenue, absorbed inside a flat margin guide. Wider market context cuts both ways. Listed alternative managers have spent the year de-rating — fee related earnings and management-fee growth sit among the worst 360-day price performers across the sector — and a holding company trading near 20% below its own marks is partly a verdict on illiquid valuations rather than on Action. 3i's rebuttal is mechanical rather than rhetorical: buy the stock back, keep 80% of the portfolio hedged against rising interest rate environments, and let Action's cash do the work. The risk is that the shrink-and-absenteeism quarter turns out to be a symptom of running a European roll-out at 12% store growth a year rather than a one-off. The next six weeks of peak trading, and a fourth quarter that has to do unusually heavy lifting, will settle it.people there are very highly taxed at all levels, and they don't have much spending money. And it is affecting a large part of the population.