OptimumBank Grew 30% a Year and Its Stock Fell 10% — the Treadmill Explains Why
A record quarter, a 4.63% margin that beats peers by 86 basis points, and a CEO openly admitting he may have to sell stock 'by hook or by crook' to keep the compounding going.
OPHC · Earnings Call · 2026-11-13
A record quarter the tape didn't reward
OptimumBank's third quarter was, on the page, the best in its 26-year history. Record net income of roughly $7.2 million, up 7.8% sequentially and 65.9% year over year. Diluted EPS of $0.30 versus $0.18 a year ago. Net interest income of $16.78 million, net interest margin out to 4.63%, pre-tax pre-provision earnings of $10.6 million that annualize to more than $42 million, a core return on average equity of 29.6%, and an efficiency ratio of 45.86% against a peer average of 62.74%. Total assets crossed $1.58 billion, loans $1.37 billion, deposits $1.34 billion, tangible book value per diluted share $5.98. And yet the stock is down 8% over the last 65 sessions and 10.6% below its August 19 peak of $10.10 — even though shares closed September 30 at $8.72, up nearly 50% from $5.88 on July 1 on roughly fourteen times the prior daily volume. The operating story and the equity story have decoupled. The reason is not credit, and it is not loan demand. Net interest income has gone from roughly a million dollars a quarter in the mid-2010s to $16.8 million this quarter. That is the whole story of the franchise: a deposit-gathering, lend-it-out, wash-rinse-repeat machine in South Florida that management says has a borrower queue of about $700 million, or as the CEO put it, “our pipeline today collectively is like $700 million now” — Moishe Gubin, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-13.The treadmill nobody wants to name
The global keyword table for this quarter reads like the whole industry is arguing about deposits and rates — core deposits sits in the market's top ten, flanked by cost of deposits and lending rates. OptimumBank's answer is essentially that the argument does not apply to it: “South Florida seems to be immune to a lot of that” — Moishe Gubin, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-13. But there is a different constraint, and the company's own top-ranked keyword this quarter — capital position — is the tell. In August it sold $35 million of sub debt, downstreaming $31 million into the bank and lifting the Tier 1 leverage ratio to 12.23%. After quarter-end it raised another $25.4 million of common equity from four accredited investors, at roughly a 10% discount to market. And 2027 is already spoken for:The arithmetic is explicit and unusually candid. Grow loans $500 million, hold a 10% capital ratio, and you need $50 million of equity; earn $40 million and you have a shortfall. Pay a dividend and the shortfall gets bigger, which is why the board keeps deferring it: “That still remains a subject of debate at the board level” — Moishe Gubin, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-13. The private-placement route is genuinely company-unique — “The cost of doing the private deal is zero” — Moishe Gubin, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-13 — but it also seeds future float, since those unregistered shares become registered six months later. Growth here is funded by continuously selling paper into a thin tape, and the market is pricing that. Common equity has climbed from $14 million in 2020 to $127 million, and still the balance sheet outruns it. Leverage tells the same story from the other side: liabilities to assets sits at 90.0%, down eight points since 2015 but still the structural reason capital is the binding constraint, not demand.I would expect that in 2027, we will raise money by hook or by crook, either through an ATM or through an offering or through private. Most likely it'll be in somewhere $50 million raise at some point.
What management quietly stopped promising
The most interesting contrast is the allowance. In August, the CFO was explicit about direction:Three months later the allowance for credit losses to loans is 0.89% — lower, not higher. Provision expense was $1.07 million against a $37,000 reversal in the prior quarter, so the dollar reserve did build, but the ratio did not move the way it was guided. The CFO's explanation now leans on the qualitative side — “Where I think the allowance itself will grow a little bit is in its Q factors” — Elliot Nunez, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-13 — with concentration and volume, plus the OptimumFinance book, adding through 2027. The CEO's framing is blunter: the board debated topping it up to look more like peers, but “The reality is that it's really not needed because we don't have loans that are going bad” — Moishe Gubin, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-13. That is consistent with a decade of prior language — “our battle is the fact that we have no bad loans” — Moishe Gubin, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) · 2026-08-13 — but consistency is not the same as delivery. Note also what fell out of the conversation. Last quarter's Q&A was dominated by loan concentration, legal lending limits, and owner-occupied CRE. This quarter, concentration never came up in the live session. The company's own Q factors framing has replaced it. Meanwhile the market's top-75 keyword list now carries Reserve strengthening — the rest of the sector is building, OptimumBank is explaining why it need not.I think we're going to be rising above that 91 and getting much closer to the 1% for the rest of the year.