Pollard Banknote’s Contract Haul Meets Its Manufacturing Broken Record
Q3 revenue rose, but margins fell and the same production issues resurfaced—again. The wins are real; the execution discount is too.
PBL.TO · Earnings Call · 2026-11-09
The contracts are real; the quarter was not
Pollard Banknote’s Q3 2026 revenue rose to $158.9 million from $156.3 million, but gross profit fell to $24.3 million, or 15.3% of sales, from $28.1 million and 18.0%. Adjusted EBITDA dropped to $28.3 million from $32.3 million, and net income fell to $8.1 million, or $0.30 per share, from $10.3 million and $0.38. The revenue bridge was messy: higher increasing revenue from ancillary lottery products and services added $3.4 million, charitable average selling price added $1.6 million, and eTab revenue added $1.5 million. Those gains were partly offset by a $3.5 million hit from lower instant ticket average selling price and a $5.5 million decline from the Michigan iLottery contract expiry. Management also flagged a less favorable customer mix and production inefficiencies. There was no attempt to dress it up. John Pollard said “this past quarter was very disappointing from that perspective of the manufacturing issues we had in our instant ticket operations during the quarter.” — John Pollard, Co-CEO · 2026-11-09 Doug Pollard framed the quarter as one where “Although our Q3 operating results are lower than we expected, a significant number of positive developments occurred during the third quarter...” — Douglas Pollard, Co-CEO · 2026-11-09 Both things are true: the demand pipeline is strong, but the quarter itself was a margin miss.The win streak is genuine—and strategically selective
The positive developments are not cosmetic. Pollard won a new five-year Kansas iLottery contract with a two-year extension, secured the final one-year extension on North Carolina through June 2029, was named apparent winner in Colorado, launched playON with Oklahoma, and won back Norsk Tipping’s instant ticket business with what John Pollard called a “significant price increase.” It also declined to bid Virginia’s iLottery RFP—not because demand is weak, but because implementation capacity is finite. Doug Pollard said the company needed to “preserve some capacity for some of those other opportunities.” — Douglas Pollard, Co-CEO · 2026-11-09 That is a mature portfolio decision. It protects the iLottery contract pipeline, especially North Carolina’s expected 2027 RFP, rather than chasing every RFP. It also signals that new contract wins now compete for implementation resources, not just sales effort. The digital book is broadening—Belgium, Kansas, Colorado, Oklahoma—but it is also getting more expensive before it gets more profitable.The broken record: manufacturing
The uncomfortable part is that this is not a new problem. Analyst Stephen Boland asked the question directly: “how do you get confidence the manufacturing issues are behind you? Because this is -- is it a year ago, 1.5 year ago, there were some other manufacturing issues.” — Stephen Boland, Analyst · 2026-11-09 The prior calls show the same movie. In Q1 2025, John Pollard explained that “the cause of a good portion of some of the high spoilage that we had in the first quarter was due to the fact that the nature of the products we produce is constantly evolving.” — John Pollard, Co-CEO · 2026-08-13 In May 2025, asked whether spoilage was under control, he said “this is just a risk of always being in this business.” — John Pollard, Co-Chief Executive Officer · 2025-05-10 By Q2 2026, management was pointing to manufacturing efficiencies improving; by Q3 2026, rework and spoilage were back. The company has installed new manufacturing management in Winnipeg and Ypsilanti, and John Pollard argues the long-term trajectory is better. But he also conceded:That is honest—and exactly why the market should treat the margin recovery as a show-me story rather than a quarter-specific blip. The same analyst concern has now surfaced across multiple quarters; that is a pattern, not bad luck.There is no one sort of silver bullet change. It's a number of blocking and tackling things that we have to do a little bit better.