Power Corp.'s Wealthsimple Windfall Comes With an Accounting Bill
Q3 showed 57% NAV growth and a narrower discount, but carried interest turns the group's best asset into an earnings drag — and simplification is still more tease than transaction.
POW.TO · Earnings Call · 2026-11-12
The Raison d'Être Gets an Upgrade
Power Corporation's third quarter was, on the surface, more of the same success story: adjusted EPS of $1.53, up 13% year over year; net asset value per share of $113.28, up 57% year over year; and a discount to that NAV that has narrowed to roughly 20%. But the call revealed a subtle shift in how CEO James O'Sullivan is framing the holdco. Active ownership is no longer just an operating philosophy — it is now the company's stated reason for being. “I think it's very important that every holding company be able to articulate raison d'être, a reason for being. And ours is to engage in active ownership across a portfolio of financial services companies globally.” — James O’Sullivan · 2026-11-12 That matters because it reframes the discount-to-NAV debate. If active ownership is the product, then the market's skepticism is a judgment on that product — not just on the sum of the parts. O'Sullivan was unusually direct about the feedback loop: "If the discount to NAV was 10%, I'd probably be speaking about it a bit less. But I really do think that north of 10%, ... I feel obliged to really lean in on these things." That is a CEO telling you the buyback and simplification levers are permanently on the table while the gap persists.The Wealthsimple Paradox
The quarter's most interesting tension sits inside Wealthsimple. The group's collective interest in the fintech is now valued at $5 billion, up 13% from last quarter, with $170 billion in assets under administration and roughly 4 million Canadian clients. On any strategic scorecard, that is a win. But because of how the stake is held and compensated, the accounting runs the other way. Carried interest — the share of gains owed to Sagard's team — flows through the income statement as an expense. The better Wealthsimple performs, the larger the accrued carry liability, and the bigger the reported loss at the holdco. Jake Lawrence, the CFO, was blunt about the mechanics: "unfortunately, the way the carried interest is accounted for, it's an expense item, and we're not taking -- we're not going to find a way to adjust that differently."That is a rare case where a company's best asset makes its P&L look worse precisely when it is doing better. Investors have to look through the net of carry figure to see the value creation. Management deserves credit for disclosure — they quantified the drag and flagged the eventual offset — but the episode explains why the shares can lag the underlying NAV growth even as the operating companies outperform.unfortunately, the way the carried interest is accounted for, it's an expense item, and we're not taking -- we're not going to find a way to adjust that differently. ... At some point, they'll turn to a share of earnings, and that will come through at the same time and partially offset it.