Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

Security National: A 37% Earnings Drop That Added $36 Million to Book Value

Rising rates gutted the mortgage unit and revalued life reserves upward in the same quarter — and the decade-old buyback question got the same non-answer.
SNFCA · Earnings Call · 2026-11-12

Two statements, pulling in opposite directions

Scott Quist did not try to soften the quarter. Pretax earnings fell 37%, the mortgage segment swung from a $66,000 profit to a $2.65 million loss, and net income landed near $6.2 million. Then he explained why the balance sheet told the opposite story.

we had what we believe is the largest single quarter dollar increase in stockholders' equity in our history, with equity increasing some $36 million, or 8.2% for the quarter to $469 million... both results as divergent as they may seem, are driven primarily by the same macro factor, i.e., increased interest rates.

Scott Quist, Chairman and CEO · 2026-11-12
The mechanism is duration. Security National's life liabilities run longer than its assets, so when discount rates jump, reserves get marked down and the difference bypasses the income statement entirely, flowing through other comprehensive income into equity. Garrett Sill quantified it: a pretax benefit of nearly $52 million in the quarter and almost $65 million year-to-date from remeasuring future policy benefits, against $23 million in the first nine months of 2025. Bond holdings took the mirror-image hit — about $15 million of pretax unrealized losses in the quarter. This is not operating improvement, and management says so. But it is real capital, and it is why liabilities to assets ticked down to 73.1%, four points better than a year ago, and why the debt-to-equity ratio now reads 2.47x. The catch: interest coverage of 9.1x sits well below the 16.7x peak. Equity that arrives via rate marks can leave the same way.

The mortgage segment's ten-quarter low

A 90-basis-point rise in 30-year rates during the quarter did the damage. Andrew Quist was blunt: “The rise in interest rates resulted in SNMC's lowest quarterly origination volume in 10 quarters.” — Scott Quist, Chairman and CEO · 2026-11-12 Volume came in at $470 million versus $622 million, a 24% year-over-year decline, with market share slipping to 9 basis points from 10. Two pockets grew anyway — reverse mortgage originations more than doubled (+187%) and HELOC originations rose 128% — which is the kind of mix shift that matters more than the headline. Loans per loan officer rose 9%, and the company has cut $14 million of expense year-over-year plus another $2.5 million of annualized savings. That is the difference between a bad quarter and a broken business. This is not a private story, though. The market-wide keyword board for the latest quarter is crowded with rate language — Fed rate hike, rising interest rate environments, impact of high rates — and Security National's own increase in interest rates theme is simply the same tide arriving at a balance sheet deliberately built to be levered to it.

The buyback question that will not die

The most instructive moment came from a five-year shareholder, Curtis Thompson, who pointed out that the stock trades around $9 against a book value he pegged at $16-17 — a discount he called out as rare among peers. Scott Quist's response was a two-part defense. First, the GAAP book is inflated relative to the statutory book regulators actually watch; the reserve revaluation that just added ~$88 million of GAAP equity does not exist on a statutory basis. Second: “the deployment of capital should occur in growing operations, not in reducing our shareholders' equity.” — Scott Quist, Chairman and CEO · 2026-11-12 He has said versions of this for a decade. In 2016, pressed on a dividend: “a company can only buy back shares or pay a cash dividend if it does not have a better use for those funds.” — Scott M. Quist, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2016-04-05 In 2025, pressed on a 4-5% return on tangible equity: “beauty is in the eye of the beholder.” — Scott Quist, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2025-05-15 The company does buy back small amounts — $785,521 last quarter, up 224% year-over-year, though far below the $7 million peak in 2022 — and the pattern is consistent: a persistent valuation gap, a persistent shareholder complaint, and a persistent reinvestment answer.

What is genuinely new

Three things shifted this quarter. First, credit loss provision jumped to a top-15 company theme — a genuine change in emphasis, not boilerplate. A roughly $2 million CECL provision tied to two loans that defaulted; mortgages more than 90 days delinquent or in foreclosure rose to $17.5 million from $15.8 million at mid-year and just $6.5 million at year-end 2025, with about $11 million in foreclosure, $7.5 million of it commercial. Second, the 10-Q disclosed that SecurityNational Mortgage missed the quarterly net income covenant on two warehouse lines — “Since then, we obtained every waiver we needed, which just arrived after the 10-Q was filed.” — Garrett Sill, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-12 A timing footnote, but a signal that the mortgage subsidiary is running close to its tripwires. Third, death rate became the company's number-one keyword — a quietly elegant new frame. Low mortality cost the cemetery segment (families served down 1.3% year-to-date) while improving insurance mortality results by about $800,000. That is the natural hedge management keeps advertising, now showing up in the language. On the insurance side, new sales rose more than 20% by annualized premium and 27-30% by face — the payoff from replacing nearly the entire senior sales team — but Adam Quist conceded new business is mildly profit-negative in year one, a point the company made in 2025 as well. And the average portfolio yield fell 90 basis points year-over-year yet held in the mid-5% range versus a mid-4% industry, which is the durable part of the franchise.

The bet, in one line

The operating business prints roughly $6 million a quarter and trades at 7.4x earnings, while the balance sheet quietly gains from every rate increase and loses from every cut. Nothing about that changed in Q3 — which is exactly the story. The equity growth is a macro mark, the mortgage pressure is a macro mark, and the buyback debate remains the same conversation Security National has been having with its own shareholders since 2016.