Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

Spire Trades a 2027 Dollar for a 2031 Rate Base

FY27 guidance lands about $0.60 below the path Spire laid out in August — but FY28 holds, the long-term CAGR rises to 6-8%, and a customer-funded pipeline project finally turns four quarters of load-growth talk into an asset.
SR · Earnings Call · 2026-11-17

The Cut That Wasn't Quite a Cut

Three months ago, Wolfe's David Paz pressed Scott Doyle on the shape of Spire's 2028 rebase, asking whether FY28 would land at the high end of the 5-7% band off "$5.75 in '27." Doyle's answer was one word: “Yes.” — Scott Doyle, President and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-08-05 Last night's FY27 guide is $5.05 to $5.25 — midpoint $5.15, roughly $0.60, or about 10%, below the number that was sitting in front of investors in August. And yet FY28 comes in at $6.10 to $6.30, essentially on the trajectory implied by $5.75 compounding at 5-7%. The long-term CAGR goes up, not down, to 6-8% through fiscal 2031 off the FY28 midpoint. So the headline is a cut; the substance is a re-phasing. The dollars did not evaporate, they slid a year to the right.

The main impact there really is the Tennessee ARM interpretation coming in lower than our main assumption... I hesitate to put a strict number on Tennessee, but it's significantly more than that, just given the buildup of capital there.

Adam Woodard, Executive Vice President and CFO · 2026-11-17
Tennessee is the culprit. The adjustable rate mechanism that transferred with the acquisition carries a 4% annual cap on base rate increases, and the commission applied that cap to margin rather than to base rates — a materially tighter reading than Spire underwrote. Alabama contributes a smaller $0.03-0.04. Layer on the Missouri under-recovery, and Woodard is explicit that they have deliberately built a negative variance allowance into FY27 rather than assume the mechanism behaves. Doyle's read is that the jurisdiction is still fine — “We do find Tennessee still to be incredibly constructive and there was no restriction on filing a case in Tennessee, which is what's driving our path forward.” — Scott Doyle, President and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-17 The fix is a rate case in the first half of calendar 2027, with rates effective late in the year and the full benefit landing in FY28 — which is precisely why FY28 is the new rebasing year.

Regulatory Execution: The Pitch and the Punchline

Regulatory execution has been Spire's core equity story for at least four quarters. This quarter it was also the thing that cost shareholders $0.60. That tension is the real content of the print. The Missouri future test year filing is the centerpiece: a $228 million revenue requirement, $171 million of net new revenue plus $57 million of ISRS revenue moved into base, $5.1 billion of average rate base, a 10.5% ROE request and a 55% equity ratio, with new rates October 1, 2027. Doyle is not pretending a settlement is likely: “I would say we should expect this case to go the distance just by nature of it being a case of first impression for the future test year.” — Scott Doyle, President and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-17 Management is also candid that the case needs to deliver more than money — it needs the weather fix. The weather normalization saga is now four calls long. In February they filed an accounting authority order; by May they were explaining that “usage per HDD came down quite a bit over those two years” — Adam W. Woodard, CFO · 2026-05-06; in August came a settlement committing to a durable solution. Fiscal 2026 weather-normalized margin recovery came in roughly $24 million light, and the proposed decoupling-style mechanism is now embedded in the rate case itself. Watching whether weather normalized margin recovery finally stops being a quarterly variable is the single best test of whether the FY28 base is real.

MoGas: The Load-Growth Tease Finally Lands

For a year, Spire has been gesturing at gas-fired generation demand without a name attached. In February:

the opportunity there for us is to serve generation needs either as they convert coal to gas or as new gas plants come online. We're active in talking to different parties, but don't have anything to announce.

Scott Edward Doyle, President and CEO · 2026-02-03
Now there is something. The MoGas expansion adds more than 350,000 dekatherms per day of Zone 3 capacity to serve Ameren Missouri's West Alton Energy Center, a new combined-cycle gas plant, under a 20-year negotiated rate agreement. The structure is what makes it interesting. “This is an addition of compression to existing pipe... and then obviously funded -- fully funded by the customer.” — Scott Doyle, President and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-17 Zero Spire capital, no rate-base lag, earnings during construction from the tax gross-up on customer contributions in aid of construction, then roughly $15 million annually once in service in fiscal 2030. It is the highest-return-per-unit-of-risk project in the plan, and it sits squarely on the gas-to-power theme that has dominated utility capex conversations this year. It also explains why pace of investment is a keyword here in a way it wasn't a year ago: management went out of its way to say the higher growth target does not require accelerating spend.

What Quietly Got Trimmed

Three things deserve more attention than they got on the call. First, the credit target moved. For several quarters Adam Woodard anchored investors on 15-16% FFO to debt, describing in November 2025 “a pretty steady movement up into the middle of the threshold bands, both Moody's and S&P.” — Scott Edward Doyle, President and CEO · 2025-11-14 Last night's language is 14-15%, reached in fiscal 2028-2029. The $5.8 billion non-current debt balance, up 65% year over year is why. A one-point trim to a stated leverage target is small in isolation and meaningful in aggregate. Second, the dividend. The 4.8% raise to $3.46 is below the newly raised 6-8% EPS growth target and far below FY27's 28% step-up. Against FY26's $4.02 that is an 86% payout — well above the 55-65% band management has cited for two years. The math works by FY28 ($3.46 against $6.20 is 56%), but the modest raise is a tell: the payout had stretched during the transition and now needs earnings to catch up to it. Third, the language of the portfolio has changed completely. Divestiture now shows up in this company's keyword set only as a decliner — storage asset sales, the Mississippi subsidiary, marketing evaluation, all gone from the script. The transformation is done. What replaced it is a much narrower vocabulary: rate cases, recovery mechanisms, and pipeline contracts. That is a cleaner story, and a less optional one.

The Tape and the Rate Regime

The stock has run 6.9% over the last 90 days and sits within 3.6% of its November 4 high — into a guidance cut. Either the market pre-positioned for a re-phasing and not a de-rating, or it hasn't fully marked the Tennessee outcome. The valuation is not stretched: 8.4x net income, down 44% year over year, with capital expenditure running near $213 million a quarter. The macro overlay matters more than usual here. The global keyword set for this quarter is littered with Fed rate hike language, and Woodard confirmed the posture directly: “We would characterize ourselves in the... higher for longer camp on an interest rate perspective. I do expect certainly a couple of hikes from the Fed.” — Adam Woodard, Executive Vice President and CFO · 2026-11-17 A 10.5% Missouri ROE request and a 14-15% FFO-to-debt target are being prosecuted into a market that is pricing the opposite of relief. That, not the $0.60, is what determines whether FY28 is the base or just the next ledge. Constraint discipline is real — “we're balancing all of this against affordability as well” — Scott Doyle, President and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-17 — and the $0-50 million annual ATM is the only equity ask. But the whole thesis now hangs on three regulators in three states agreeing with a company that just told you it misread one of them.