StubHub Raised the Top Line, Kept the Bottom Line — and the Stock Kept Falling
A record 25% EBITDA margin and half a turn of deleveraging, but the two options that were supposed to change the story are still in beta — and the CFO is leaving
STUB · Earnings Call · 2026-11-10
A record margin the market won't pay for
By the letter of the release, StubHub's third quarter was its best as a public company. GMS rose 7% to $2.6 billion, adjusted EBITDA jumped 84% to $124 million, and the company booked what Eric Baker called “our highest EBITDA margin quarter as a public company” — Eric H. Baker, Founder, Chairman, and CEO · 2026-11-10 — 25%, up ten points year over year. Sales and marketing fell to 45% of revenue, nine points better. Full-year GMS guidance went up to 11–13% growth from 10–12%, with the $400–420 million EBITDA range reiterated. The tape disagrees violently. STUB sits 74.6% below its $22.00 post-IPO peak and has lost 56% in the last 90 days alone, leaving a market cap just under $2 billion. The break came around the August print and never repaired. So the real question on this call was never "did you hit the number" — it was "is the margin a World Cup artifact or a flywheel?" Management answered the first question cleanly and the second only in half measures.The quarter's loudest keyword was the term loan
The top-momentum theme in this quarter's set isn't growth at all: it's Term Loan. That tells you where the substance was. Connie James walked through a genuine balance-sheet transformation — net leverage down to 2.5x from 4.5x at year-end 2025, $1.1 billion of debt repaid since the IPO, a 3.5-year maturity extension to October 2033, a 25bp cost reduction, and a Moody's upgrade from B3 to B2 in September. Cash stands at $1.2 billion, or roughly $417 million net of seller obligations, with $1.2 billion of NOLs still shielding taxes. Revenue is the other half of the story, and it explains the tape: $573 million in the last filed quarter, up 33% year over year. Then Q3 revenue came in at $502 million, up 7%. That deceleration from +33% to +7% is arithmetic, not deterioration — but it is exactly the shape that makes a de-rating stick.The fourth quarter is a calendar problem, and management wants you to know it
Take rate behaved as promised, recovering from about 18.5% during the World Cup to over 19% and tracking toward the historical 20% for the year; gross margin returned to 85%. What's left is a comp set management spent real airtime defusing: the first general World Cup ticket release lands in December, and the MLB playoffs pitted the league's smallest markets against each other — Cleveland, Milwaukee and Tampa in the LCS, and the two smallest-market clubs in a five-game World Series versus last year's Blue Jays–Dodgers seven-gamer. On top of that sits the genuinely uncontrollable variable, concert on sales, where promoters, not StubHub, choose the timing.Strip those three items out and Baker pegs underlying growth in the high single digits. That is consistent with the story of an experience economy still expanding — but it is no longer the double-digit glide path the equity was priced for at IPO. Note too that this is a rerun: in August, analysts pressed almost the identical point about implied second-half growth and North America looking flat.The key unknown is really in relation to these concert on sales and the timing associated with it. Hence, why we have given you a bit of a larger range than perhaps you're traditionally used to in the fourth quarter.
The two options that keep slipping
Advertising has now been "tens of millions" for three straight quarters. In March, Baker framed it as getting the product right. In August he said the team was “really focused on just getting it right before we'll be in a position to share more metrics on how it's going” — Eric Baker, Founder, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer · 2026-08-12. In November, James repeated the same scale — “it would be an immaterial amount, call it in the tens of millions of dollars” — Constance James, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-10 — while confirming any real disclosure waits for the 2027 call. sponsored listing adoption is wider, now tested with fan sellers and not just professional point-of-sale users, but it remains a rounding error against a $10 billion GMS base. Open distribution has travelled a similar arc. A year ago direct issuance was the number-one keyword on this call; by March the company said it was “deliberately shifting to a longer-term focus” — Eric Baker, CEO · 2026-03-05 to build self-serve product rather than chase revenue. The awkward detail this quarter: the NFL — the sport that most benefits from exclusivity — announced an open-distribution regime that StubHub is not in.That is a thesis validation and a competitive miss in the same sentence. The Big 12 football and basketball partnership is the nearer-term proof point.We are very excited to see that the National Football League, which is arguably the premier sports property in North America, came out and actually embraced open distribution. How it works out that we do or do not work specifically with the NFL will have to leave for a later date.