Open in interactive viewer → charts, metric popovers & call review

Ülker’s Second Cut: The Margin Story Is Now a Credibility Story

Volume held and brands still lead, but a lower guidance range, a cocoa inventory lag, and a CEO still selling the plan leave investors asking what normal looks like.
ULKER.IS · Earnings Call · 2026-11-09

The second cut is the story

Ülker’s 9 November call was not a normal quarterly update. It was the moment a margin problem became a credibility problem. The CEO opened the outlook with the numbers investors had been bracing for: “We now expect a single-digit decline in full year net sales ... We have also revised our EBITDA margin guidance ... to 9% to 11% from 13.5% plus/minus 1.5 percentage points.” — Ozgur Kolukfaki, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-09 That is a hard reset. In May, management had called 13.5% ±1.5 points a “conservative” plan. In August, after a weak second quarter, the CEO insisted: “We feel extremely confident on the EBITDA for the year-to-go guidance ... we have kept our EBITDA intact in our guidance.” — Ozgur Kolukfaki, CEO · 2026-08-19 Three months later, the range is 9-11%. No wonder the first analyst question was blunt:

My first question is, as the management, do you have any plan to regain the investor confidence after 3 terrible quarters? And do you see that you have the second downward revision to your estimates?

Cemal Demirtas, Analyst · 2026-11-09
The revision is the signal. Management blames a confluence of external shocks: Turkish inflation expectations moving from 23% at the start of the year to 30% at year-end, a longer promotional normalization, falling cocoa prices that make price increases harder to justify, and MENA conflict adding roughly 2 percentage points to consolidated EBITDA costs. Some of that is real. But August’s call already knew about MENA and cocoa. The new message is that the operating environment has stayed bad longer than the company’s “cautiously optimistic” assumptions allowed.

The accounting fog is real — but it is not the whole story

The call’s dominant language was accounting. IAS 29 and inflation accounting now sit at the top of Ülker’s keyword stack, and for good reason. For 9M 2026, reported revenue was TRY 95.7 billion, down 8.8% year on year, with EBITDA of TRY 11.1 billion and an 11.6% margin. Excluding IAS 29, revenue was TRY 89 billion, EBITDA TRY 13 billion and margin 14.5%. The gap gets uglier in Q3: a reported net loss of TRY 546 million versus a positive TRY 584 million ex-IAS. The CFO warned that Q4 will show an even wider IAS/non-IAS spread because the strongest sales quarter pulls more inventory — and more accumulated inflation adjustments — through cost of sales. That is a genuine distortion. But it cannot explain everything. Even on the company’s preferred ex-IAS basis, the 9M EBITDA margin was still down about 520 basis points, of which management attributes roughly 2 points to the MENA war. The remaining ~320 basis points are the uncomfortable part: cocoa inventory, promo, and pricing. The CFO was candid about the cocoa mechanics: “lower cocoa does not translate immediately to lower cost of goods sold because there is a lag between cocoa prices and how it's translated and transferred into our cost of goods sold.” — Fulya Surucu, Chief Financial Officer · 2026-11-09 Ülker is carrying high-cost inventory into a falling cocoa market. Spot prices are lower, which limits its ability to raise selling prices, while the old expensive beans still hit the P&L. That is the inventory cycle working against them, not for them. Management expects normalization in 2027, but it will not disclose coverage levels or hedge ratios. So investors are left with a promise and a cocoa price chart.

Promotion is buying volume, not margin

The operating defence is volume. Consolidated volume rose 0.6% in 9M and 0.3% in Q3; Turkey snacking volume grew 2.4%; Ülker held a 34% volume share across biscuits, chocolate and cake and gained 40 basis points in the broader snacking market to 18.4%. That is not nothing. But the price of that share is visible in the promotional data: sweet biscuit promotional volume share rose from 30% to 38%, cakes by almost 8 points, solid chocolate from 43% to 47%; shoppers now visit 3.5 stores over four weeks versus 3.3 in 2025. The CEO’s line was “we are not overpromoting. So we are trying to really manage our promo intensity in a balanced term in line with the market conditions while also watching out our profitability and also the market share.” — Ozgur Kolukfaki, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-09 The market may hear that as “we are funding the share gain.” Promo intensity is not a Turkish quirk alone; it fits the global challenging consumer conditions theme this quarter. But Ülker’s exposure is concentrated: Turkey is 70% of revenue, and even there, ex-IAS EBITDA margin was 16.4% for 9M — only a slight decline — while reported Turkey EBITDA fell 37% with IAS. The domestic business is not broken; the reported numbers are. Internationally, the cushion has become a source of volatility. MENA revenue grew 3% but EBITDA fell almost 40%; North Africa revenue rose 8% with EBITDA down 21%; Central Asia revenue fell 2.9% and 9M EBITDA was negative. The CEO flagged the ruble devaluation against an appreciating tenge and Russian parallel trade into Kazakhstan. That is a structural competitive problem, not a one-quarter FX swing. A company that once sold “international growth” as diversification is now explaining why every region is a drag.

What could change the narrative?

There are real strategic offsets, just not yet big enough. The Go Ahead brand has moved from fruit and nut bars into protein chips, high-protein bars and granola bars — a credible wellness platform and part of a broader portfolio transformation. Innovation contributed 9% of snacking revenue, 10% in Turkey and 6% internationally. That is promising, but it is not quantified in absolute profit terms and cannot offset a 500bp margin decline in the core. The CEO also repeated the strong plan language — 5H happiness growth, 5P strategy, AI pilots — but the market has heard the strategy before. What it has not heard is a 2027 number. On that, the CEO was clear: “2027 budget process is ongoing. And definitely, we will be sharing our guidance when the time comes.” — Ozgur Kolukfaki, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-09 The most interesting potential catalyst is capital allocation. Asked about buybacks, the CEO said: “This is something on the table, which we are considering, which we are evaluating for the future.” — Ozgur Kolukfaki, Chief Executive Officer · 2026-11-09 With a market cap around $576 million and the stock at depressed levels, a buyback would be a tangible signal. But management prefers to preserve flexibility given input-cost volatility and macro uncertainty. That is prudent; it is also another way of saying “not yet.” The next quarter is an accounting trough, not necessarily an operating trough. Q4 is seasonally strong, and the CFO says pre-IAS margins will be “quite good,” but she will not give a number. Investors should watch three things: whether the pre-IAS margin actually recovers, whether cocoa cost roll-off begins in 2027, and whether promotional intensity in Turkey stops rising. Until then, Ülker’s volume resilience is real, but the equity story is on hold.